Ever get tired of trying to come up with the right thing to say in that frustrating interaction with your friend, spouse, co-worker, neighbor, or roommate? Wish someone else could figure out how to reply to that crazy email or phone message you received? Let the Relationship Ghostwriter take some of the pressure off by crafting your next response for you. (Click here to find out more about the Relationship Ghostwriter.)

Three’s a Crowd


THE ASSIGNMENT
It’s tiresome to have a third party meddling in your romance. The
Relationship Ghostwriter still feels incensed upon recalling the
indignity dear Peggy Eaton suffered at the hands of Mrs. John C.
Calhoun during that blasted Petticoat Affair!
“My boyfriend of one and a half months (‘Mark’) lives with his friend and his friend's girlfriend (‘Jill’). Mark is very close with Jill - they talk about her relationship issues, they share a lot of inside jokes and tease each other constantly, and he used to visit her in her hometown before she moved in with them. After spending time around them, I end up feeling like I'm playing second fiddle to his lady-roommate, when I should really be his priority, no?

For example, I'll ask Mark to come out for drinks with me, and he'll decline because he has to study, so I leave him alone. But when Jill asks and he declines, she'll push until he gives in. Mark has a passive personality, and he’s admitted that he has a hard time saying no. Plus, Jill loves the attention Mark gives her, and I'm sure Mark loves a tall, curvy blonde giving him attention.

So far, I haven't been able to articulate my feelings on the issue to Mark. Usually, if we’re all hanging out and I witness some interaction, I’ll sulk. Definitely not the best way to handle the situation. Mark will typically notice and ask if something is wrong, but I deny that there’s a problem. Since we haven't been together very long, I'm worried that I'll come across as insecure and jealous, or that I’ll put him in an awkward situation - trying to please both Jill and me - and that's not altogether fair. I'm also worried making Jill an issue gives her what she wants - to be the center of attention and the reason that my boyfriend and I are at odds.  Maybe Mark will even defend her!

I would love for Mark to stand up to Jill, if that's the issue. Or to be as receptive to my demands as he is to hers, without me having to turn into a nagging girlfriend! And, of course, I would love for this girl to lay off Mark a little and realize that I'm supposed to be the main girl in his life. I know they're friends, and I'm fine that they're close for the most part, but she has a boyfriend! I want her to leave my boyfriend alone!”

—Jennifer


THE GHOSTWRITER’S RESPONSE

Here’s one of many direct but still respectful ways to delve into the topic of Jill with Mark.

YOU SAY: (in a comfortable tone, alone with Mark) “Jill is really fond of you, and of course it’s easy for me to see why.  You know, sometimes I wonder if you two would be in a relationship if it weren’t for her boyfriend.  I know that’s an awkward thing for me to say, but it’s occurred to me before.  Is it cool for me to ask you about that?”


THE STRATEGY
Your challenge is to find a satisfying balance between social grace (putting your best foot forward) and honesty (speaking up for what you need).  Sometimes you can do both simultaneously.  Making yourself appealing to others gets you many of the things you need.  Being assertive makes you appealing.  But sometimes you must risk making a move another person may dislike to get something you need.  If you veer too far into being appealing at the cost of being assertive, your needs will go unnoticed or unmet.

The example above shows one of many ways you could tackle the “Jill” problem honestly (being direct, assertive) and gracefully (being respectful, reasonable)—a move that will usually strengthen, not damage, a healthy relationship.  But being direct about something you want or need isn’t easy.  It feels very risky socially, especially at the beginning of a relationship.  Is it worth doing?  You feel unsatisfied, so at least it’s worth a closer look.

It’s clear that Jill is acting in bad form.  And you aren’t sure about Mark’s intentions.  What can you do?  Shift the focus to your choices, away from Jill’s or Mark’s.  Ask yourself, “Are my actions supporting my priorities?”  To get a clear picture of your priorities, first brainstorm a list of all the things you would like to see come of this situation.  Maybe it starts something like this (in no particular order):




Next—and this is really important—edit this into a list of personal goals instead of a simple wish list.  Do this by deleting or reframing items until the list contains only that which is specific and within your control.  In other words, each item must theoretically be achievable by you alone in the near future.  Here’s a start:




Now you have a sharper focus on what matters most to you.  When you’re unsure about your goals, you cannot commit to a strategy and you usually feel dissatisfied.  For instance, you described how sulking was unsatisfying.  That’s because you were in limbo, committed neither to being assertive nor being stoic.  When you have clarity about your priorities, it’s easier to commit and to make deliberate concessions when necessary to accomplish what matters most.

You may come out feeling motivated to try something new, even if that something is challenging or risky.  If you prioritize the “happy, healthy, committed relationship” standard above all else, it may motivate you to be gracefully honest with Mark about how his intimacy with Jill makes you feel.  If the relationship is up to your standards, he will be on your team and will try to make things better even if you disagree and it is challenging.  If he’s not on your team, that hurts, but it’s good to know because you are unwilling to settle for a relationship that doesn’t work for both of you.

Priorities and motivations are deeply personal, so they will be different for everyone.  What matters more than what you choose is simply that you own the decision-making process.*  Own the fact that one goal is more important to you than another.  Own the concessions you are willing to make to achieve that goal.  Deep dissatisfaction comes from feeling powerless in the face of other people’s choices.  Satisfaction and contentment come from empowering yourself by committing to specific, achievable personal goals based on your priorities.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



* Note to readers: The Relationship Ghostwriter is not saying it is okay to go murder someone as long as you own the decision-making process.  If that’s what you were thinking, stop being snarky and go talk to a spiritual advisor about Right and Wrong instead of chillin’ (yes, like a villain) here.